Click Here For Our Fall Favorites

Collection: Popular

70 products
  • Mint Chip Malted Milk Balls
  • Crunchy Kaleidoscope Gummi Bears
  • Dark Chocolate Nonpareils
  • Chocolate-Dipped Ginger
  • Passion Fruit and Mango Gummies
  • Milk or Dark Chocolate Almonds
  • Signature Chocolate Collection
  • Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Cashews
  • Chicago Mix Espresso Beans
  • Dark Chocolate Pistachios
  • Wine Gums
  • Artisanal French Nougat
  • Dark Chocolate Red Fish
  • Amy's Candy Bar Gift Card
  • Sour Gummi Worms
  • Licorice Caramel
  • Milk Chocolate Gummi Bears
  • Deluxe Nut Mix
  • Money Salt Licorice
  • Dark Chocolate Blueberries
  • Jelly Babies
  • Licorice Mix
  • Smoked Salt Praline Truffles
  • Rum Cordials
  • Belgian Dark Chocolate Bar
  • Half & Half (Sorbisar)
  • Belgian Milk Chocolate Bar
  • Wildberry Gummies
  • Apple Cider Caramels
  • Pumpkin Spice Malted Milk Balls
  • Coconut Milk Caramels
  • Dark Chocolate Coconut Creams